Box of Chocolates Protein Ice Cream

Jump to Recipe

“Life is like a box of chocolates”

And why is that? Or rather, HOW is that? Is it because you pick up the piece you want? Actually, that sounds dumb. Maybe it’s because you never know what you’re gonna get? Which… is not entirely true, but makes more sense than my first attempt. I’m gonna try to think of one more explanation before I Google it.

UMM…… because chocolate is sweet? Because getting a box of chocolates is a pleasant surprise? Because a box of chocolates is like a symbol of love and you should love your life?! Likeeeee… people just be going around saying things with no valid explanation, and we just live our lives being agreeable with it, not even knowing what it really means. Or maybe I’m the only one that don’t be knowing… listen… I didn’t sign up to be solving riddles.

I signed up to be a millionaire

…make it whatever quadruple that is, actually. Please hold. I signed up to be a QUADRILLIONAIRE, A QUINTILLIONAIRE, A SEXTILLIONAIRE!! NOT AN IMGOINGTOSOLVEALLTHERIDDLESINTHEWORLDLIKELIFEISABOXOFCHOCOLATES-ONAIRE!

And before you call me dumb… and I call you dumb back… I know it’s not actually a riddle, but it required some figuring out on my end, so I shall refer to it as I please. And what I please to do next is Google “life is like a box of chocolates.” Please hold.

I take back everything I said

I didn’t know that it came from Forrest Gump?! I would’ve thought it came long before him, but I love Forrest, and if Forrest says life is like a box of chocolates, then LIFE IS LIKE A BOX OF CHOCOLATES (I shout from the rooftop… mountaintop… whatever).

You never know what you’re gonna get. So my second guess was right, and that’s probably because Forrest was speaking it to me in the back of my head, and I didn’t even realize it. Thank you, Forrest.

No one has ever gotten me a box of chocolates

Should I be offended by this? I should have been able to scratch that off my bingo card by the end of kindergarten, sooo wtf is up with that?!

Fun fact, though: I don’t actually like chocolate… not by itself, at least. So like, if you gave me a box of solid chocolates, it would 100% be wasted. But if you gave me a box of Turtles chocolates, for example, they would 100% be devoured.

I will eat a Snickers, but not a plain Hershey bar. I will eat a Reese’s cup, but not a piece of Dove chocolate. I prefer Twix or KitKat—but KitKat over Crunch bar. Is everyone following? It’s the thought of the box of chocolates that counts, though.

Can someone send me a box of chocolates for Valentine’s Day? Thank you, and I love you in advance 💋

I had to buy my own box of chocolates

Just for this recipe. Crazy, right? Actually, not crazy, because we all deserve a box of chocolates no matter the method of acquisition, lol.

But um, yeah—as far as what I’m actually supposed to be talking about here… you know how wannabe healthy people be like, “Well, if you’re gonna have this bad thing, pair it with this good thing,” nag nag? This Box of Chocolates Protein Ice Cream literally does that for you!!

No thinking necessary—just make the ice cream and throw your chocolates on top, mix ’em in, dip ’em in, whatever floats your little chocolate boat.

Now let’s get into the recipe!

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• High in protein but still tastes like a real dessert
• Simple ingredient list with no cottage cheese or complicated steps
• White chocolate pudding mix adds richness and a smooth, creamy texture
• Chocolate mix-ins give it that classic “box of chocolates” vibe
• Perfect for Valentine’s Day or using up gifted chocolates afterward
• Customizable with any chocolate you already have on hand

Ingredients You’ll Need

This recipe is divided into the ice cream base, mix-ins, and toppings for easy prep.

Ice Cream Base

• 1½ cups (360 mL) milk
• 1 scoop (31 g) vanilla protein powder
• 14 g sugar-free white chocolate pudding mix
• 1 teaspoon stevia or sweetener of choice, to taste
• Pinch of salt

Mix-In

• 15 g chopped semi-sweet chocolate or mini chocolate chips

Toppings

• 4 pieces assorted chocolate (from any box of chocolates)

You can use sugar-free chocolates, filled chocolates, or whatever you already have.

How to Make Box of Chocolates Protein Ice Cream

Blend the base:

Add the milk, vanilla protein powder, white chocolate pudding mix, stevia, and salt to a blender. Blend until completely smooth.

Freeze:

Pour the mixture into a Ninja Creami pint container. Freeze on a flat, level surface for 24 hours.

Spin:

After freezing, remove the pint and run it under hot water for 1–2 minutes. Place it into the Ninja Creami and spin on Lite Ice Cream mode. Re-spin 1–2 times until creamy.

Add the mix-in:

If a well isn’t already formed, create one in the center of the ice cream. Add the chopped chocolate or mini chocolate chips, then spin on Mix-In mode.

Top and enjoy:

Finish with four pieces of assorted chocolate from your box of chocolates. Enjoy immediately or return to the freezer to firm up slightly.

Tips for Success

• Level freeze matters: A flat freeze helps the Creami blade spin evenly.
• Re-spin confidently: Protein ice creams almost always benefit from at least one re-spin.
• Chocolate choice is flexible: Milk, dark, filled, or sugar-free chocolates all work.
• Sweeter base needed? Adjust sweetener depending on your protein powder.
• For cleaner mix-ins: Chop chocolate finely so it distributes evenly without sinking.

Customizations

• Make it richer: Use 2% or whole milk for a creamier texture.
• White chocolate forward: Add a few white chocolate chips as the mix-in instead.
• Strawberry chocolate box vibe: Add freeze-dried strawberries as a topping.
• Extra crunch: Mix in almonds, pecans, or peanuts.
• Lower sugar option: Use sugar-free chocolates for the mix-ins and toppings.

More Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream Recipes to Try

If you loved this Box of Chocolates Protein Ice Cream, you might also enjoy:

• Strawberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
• Stracciatella Protein Ice Cream
• Oreo Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
• Red Velvet Cake Protein Ice Cream
• Cannoli Protein Ice Cream

Each one follows the same creamy, high-protein Ninja Creami formula with its own unique flavor twist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a different pudding mix?

Yes. Vanilla or cheesecake pudding mix will work, but white chocolate provides a neutral base flavor for the chocolate to shine.

What protein powder works best?

Vanilla whey protein blends most smoothly, but plant-based works too. Expect a slightly denser texture with plant-based powders.

Can I skip the mix-in step?

You can, but the chopped chocolate really gives this recipe its “box of chocolates” feel.

How do I store leftovers?

Keep the pint covered in the freezer. Before eating again, run under hot water for a minute and re-spin for best texture.

Can I make this without a Ninja Creami?

You can freeze and stir every 30 minutes or use an ice cream maker, but the Ninja Creami gives the creamiest result.

Final Thoughts

Box of Chocolates Protein Ice Cream is proof that a simple base and thoughtful toppings can turn into something that feels intentional and special. It’s sweet without being overwhelming, creamy without being heavy, and flexible enough to fit whatever chocolates you already have on hand.

Whether you’re making this for Valentine’s Day or repurposing a gifted box of chocolates, this recipe turns a classic treat into a scoopable, high-protein dessert that actually feels worth it.